University of Toronto graduate student Martin Smith has for the first time reconstructed mouthparts of two mollusk-like animals Odontogriphus and Wiwaxia that lived in Cambrian seas 500 million years ago.
Artist’s reconstruction of Wiwaxia (Nobu Tamura / Spinops.blogspot.com / CC BY-SA 3.0)
The radula sounds like something from a horror movie – a conveyor belt lined with hundreds of rows of interlocking teeth. In fact, radulas are found in the mouths of most mollusks, from the giant squid to the garden snail. Smith has found that a ‘prototype’ radula of 500-million-year-old fossils was not a flesh-rasping terror, but a tool for humbly scooping food from the muddy sea floor.
The Cambrian animals Odontogriphus and Wiwaxia might not have been much to look at – the former a naked slug, the latter a creeping bottom-dweller covered with spines and scales.
Despite the hundreds of fossil specimens collected from the Canadian Rockies by the Royal Ontario Museum, scientists could not agree whether they represented early mollusks, relatives of the earthworm, or an evolutionary dead-end.
Smith, author of a paper published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B, employed a new, non-destructive type of electron microscopy to reveal the new details.
“I put the fossils in the microscope, and the mouth parts just leaped out,” Smith said. “You could see details you’d never guess were there if you just had a normal microscope.”
After examining some 300 fossils, Smith was able not just to reconstruct the mouthparts, but work out how they grew.
“The fossils are squashed completely flat, which makes them really hard to reconstruct in 3D,” Smith explained. “I surrounded myself with micrographs of the mouth parts and lumps of plasticine, and spent weeks trying to come up with a model that made sense of the fossils.”
Left: reconstruction of the Odontogriphus mouthparts. Right: fossil of Wiwaxia, mouthparts are visible towards front (Marianne Collins / Martin Smith)
The new observations demonstrated that the mouthparts consisted of two to three rows of 17 similarly-shaped teeth, with a symmetrical central tooth and smaller teeth on the edges. The teeth would have moved round the end of a tongue in the conveyor-belt fashion seen in mollusks today, scooping food – algae or detritus – from the muddy sea floor. By establishing how the teeth were arranged, moved, grew, and were replaced, Smith was able to demonstrate that they formed a shorter and squatter forerunner to the modern radula.
“When I set out, I just hoped to be a bit closer to knowing what these mysterious fossils were,” Smith said. “Now, with this picture of the earliest radula, we are one step closer to understanding where the mollusks came from and how they became so successful today.”
_______
Bibliographic information: Martin R. Smith. 2012. Mouthparts of the Burgess Shale fossils Odontogriphus and Wiwaxia: implications for the ancestral molluscan radula. Proc. R. Soc. B. Published online before print August 22, 2012; doi: 10.1098/rspb.2012.1577
